Which Sales Personality Wins in 2025: Lone Wolves vs. Collaborators.

Good Morning. It’s International Beer and Pizza Day… something everyone can get behind. Whether you’re celebrating a closed deal or numbing the pain of a lost one, beer and pizza will always be there for you. Fun fact: the modern pizza we know today came from Italy, but people have been making pizza-like flatbreads since ancient Egypt, Greece, and Rome. Try using that as an icebreaker on your sales call today. Now, let’s get into today’s Follow Up. (:

Sponsor The Follow Up | Subscribe

There was a time when the "Lone Wolf" ruled every sales floor.

You know the type… the rep who crushed quota without following the playbook, never logged calls, ignored marketing, and still (somehow) walked out with President's Club tickets every year.

That era’s dying fast.

B2B sales these days is becoming a team sport. 

Deals stretch across product, marketing, customer success, legal, and finance. And on the buyer side, there’s 6 to 10 stakeholders all expecting a VIP experience.

So we sent the intern out into our favorite places on the internet to find out what sales personality is working the best right now, and which ones you should avoid. 

The "Lone Wolf" became legendary thanks to The Challenger Sale. These reps were confident, independent, and allergic to process. They made up about 18% of sales teams and often dominated the leaderboards.

But something weird is happening.

Recent research on 315 B2B reps found that lone wolf tendencies actually hurt performance in modern sales environments.

The study found that higher lone wolf tendencies also correlate with lower job satisfaction, which indirectly hurts sales performance by destroying "contextual behaviors" like helping others or sharing information.

Translation: The same independence that used to fuel results now limits them.

An earlier study of 331 pharmaceutical reps found the exact same pattern - lone wolf tendencies showed a negative effect on cooperative behaviors like courtesy and sportsmanship, which led to weaker performance and higher turnover.

The takeaway: Lone wolves still close deals, but they can burn bridges in the process. And those bridges now carry revenue across departments.

Successful reps have figured out that collaboration is effective.

They know when to bring in a sales engineer for technical questions. They loop in marketing to see how they can help. They ask customer success to join calls so handoffs feel seamless.

This orchestration pays dividends. 

A multi-company study of value selling methods (which rely on cross-functional alignment) found a 48% lift in win rates and 35% larger deal sizes in organizations that adopted it. 

Buyers notice when a vendor's team feels aligned, and they definitely notice when it doesn't.

Collaboration also compounds learning. Reps who share battle stories and insights build collective knowledge that scales across the entire team. One rep's breakthrough becomes ten others' playbook.

And yes… teamwork can get messy. Meetings multiply, Slack threads are all over the place, and decision cycles slow down. But the trade-off is usually worth it. 

There's another hidden cost to going solo. It’s trust.

A 2022 study of 135 B2B salespeople found that stronger lone wolf tendencies were strongly correlated with lower ethical behavior, especially when reps felt unsupported by their managers. 

The more confident and unsupervised the rep, the higher the risk of cutting corners.

In regulated or high-trust industries, that becomes a massive liability. 

As buying committees grow and compliance scrutiny tightens, "lone wolf" behavior can quickly turn into brand risk.

The goal isn't to kill off the lone wolf completely. It's about evolving it.

The best modern reps blend the confidence of a lone wolf with the coordination skills of a collaborator. They know when to run fast and when to bring the team behind them.

You see this in top "Challenger" reps - they challenge assumptions, make bold moves, and still keep the cross-functional machine running smoothly. 

For managers, the play is to channel independence. Set clear expectations for visibility, reward shared learning, and design incentives that celebrate team success without killing individual drive.

The smartest teams protect individual edge while taming ego.