The Real Path From BDR to AE, and the Mistake That Will Set You Back

Good Morning. New research says that the US is in a productivity boom right now, but it’s not because of AI. Apparently, the increase in productivity is because more people are working from home. Less commuting, fewer distractions, and more output. But I think they forgot to factor in vibes. There's nothing like being in a sales bullpen, ripping cold calls while the rep next to you closes a deal. Your kitchen table can't replicate that. Now, let's get into today's Follow Up. (:

Ask what they’ve already tried 🗣
75+ sales emails that convert ✍
The BDR → AE promotion 👀
Making 6-figures in sales is getting harder 😬
Sales jobs & a meme 😂

Sponsor The Follow Up | Subscribe

Sales Tip of The Day 💡

When a prospect tells you about a problem, ask what they've already tried to fix it.

❌ "Got it, that's exactly what we solve."
✅ "Before I jump in, what have you already tried to fix this?"

It’s easy to hear a problem and immediately start pitching the solution.

The better move is to find out what's already been attempted, because the answer tells you three things:

How long they've been living with the pain?
What didn't work?
What kind of solution they've already mentally ruled out?

Turn Prospect Silence into Sales Opportunities

Fed up with emails that vanish into the void? Our collection of 75 field-tested templates delivers what others just promise: responses. No fluff, no jargon – just emails prospects actually read and reply to.

You'll get:

25 first-touch templates that spark real conversations
30 follow-up templates that keep deals moving
20 break-up templates that preserve future opportunities

These aren't theoretical best practices. They're battle-tested messages used by successful sales teams to land meetings and close deals. Each template is designed for quick customization – swap in your details and start seeing results.

Download Now 👉

How to Navigate the Most Common (and Frustrating) Promotion in Sales

If you're a BDR right now, you've probably done the math.

There’s 20 BDRs on your team and maybe 2 AE spots opening up this year. The promotion path you were sold in the interview is starting to feel a lot less like a ‘for sure’ thing.

About 70% of SDRs eventually move into an AE role. In most orgs, the timeline is 12 to 18 months. But "eventually" and "guaranteed" are two very different things. And if you're not careful, the move you make to speed things up could be the one that sets you back.

Tenure Matters More Than You Think

The Bridge Group tracked SDR-to-AE promotions across hundreds of SaaS companies and found something that should make every BDR think twice about rushing the process.

SDRs who were promoted with 11 or fewer months of experience had a 55% failure rate as AEs. More than half of them lasted six months or less in the role before getting canned.

On the flip side, SDRs who had 16 or more months of experience had a 6% failure rate.

I like those odds a whole lot better. That's basically the difference between a coin flip and a near certainty, simply by staying in the BDR role for an extra 7 months.

The average tenure before a successful promotion is about 17.5 months.

But don’t take away the wrong lesson here… just because someone’s been at a company longer, doesn’t mean they’re going to be way better at sales. This data just shows that getting experience and a base set of skills is a major indicator of how successful someone will be as they move up.

The Jumping Ship Trap

I see this one a lot…

You're 10 months in. The AE spots at your company are filled. Another company reaches out with a BDR role, better base pay, and a recruiter who promises a "fast track to AE".

So you jump. And now you're back at zero. New company, new product, new team, new management. You have to rebuild every relationship, re-prove yourself, and earn trust from scratch. So that "fast promotion path" they promised is actually another 12 months before you're even in the conversation.

I've experienced this firsthand. In my first BDR role, I jumped to a different company when I was one of the next up for promotion to an SMB AE. My second BDR role ended up paying more in base and OTE than the AE role would have, and I met a lot of great people. No regrets, but I would have gotten to AE much quicker if I stayed.

In most cases, I'd tell any BDR to stick it out where you are. Get promoted there. Once you have AE on your resume, your options open up tenfold. You can go anywhere as an AE instead of starting over as a BDR at a new company and going straight to the back of the line.

How to Make Sure You're Next Up

If you're going to stay, make sure you're doing more than hitting quota and waiting.

Ask your manager directly what the promotion criteria are and when the next AE spot is expected to open. If they can't give you a clear answer to either question, that probably tells you something.

But by far, the biggest thing you can do is start doing the job before you have the title. Sit in on AE calls. Learn the full sales cycle, run discovery like an AE, and build relationships with AE managers.

During my time at Amazon, promotions worked this way by design. To move up, you had to show that you'd already been operating at the next level. The promotion was just the formality that got you a new title (and pay bump).

Most sales orgs work the same way, even if they don't say it out loud.

A study found that 56% of executives already knew who they wanted to promote before they evaluated all the candidates. The way you become that person is by making the promotion feel like a formality, because your manager already sees you doing AE-level work every day.