How Tiny Lies Can Ruin Your Sales Career

Good Morning. Oxford just crowned “rage bait” as Word of the Year, which means online content designed to provoke outrage from people for attention and clicks. In sales, it’s the equivalent of your manager jumping into a deal at the 11th hour, says one line on the call, and somehow gets the credit for closing the deal. Instant engagement. Immediate rage. Now, let’s get into today’s Follow Up. (:

Sponsor The Follow Up | Subscribe

Your reputation takes years to build and about 30 seconds to completely obliterate.

One small exaggeration. One gentle misrepresentation. One "harmless" stretch of the truth.

That's all it takes to transform you from a trusted advisor into just another salesperson who no one believes.

These tiny shortcuts can feel harmless in the moment, but compound into career-ending reputation damage.

Today I'm breaking down the psychology behind why salespeople lie, the hidden costs that destroy careers, and how to build unshakeable credibility instead. Let's get into it.

A rep is three deals short of quota with five days left in the quarter.

Their manager is breathing down their neck, and their comp plan means the difference between paying cash for their next vacation or putting it on credit.

A buyer asks "Does your product do X?" and the honest answer is "Not yet, but it's on the roadmap for Q3."

But that answer might kill the deal. So the rep says, "Yes, we can handle that," and figures they'll deal with the consequences later.

This first compromise creates a neural pathway that makes the next one easier.

Research from the University of London found that lying becomes easier with repetition. The study showed that the brain's amygdala (the thing that processes emotional responses) shows less activity each time someone lies.

Your brain literally adapts to make dishonesty feel more comfortable over time. Before long, you've built a bad habit.

These aren't the big, obvious lies that get salespeople fired. These are the subtle little ones that slide under the radar…

"I’ll send that over right after this," when you know you won’t.
"Coming very soon" without any plans for an actual release.
Describing major limitations as "minor gaps we're actively working on."
Calling a brand new customer a "long-term partner."

All of these feel justifiable in the moment. But buyers experience them as breaches of trust, even if they can't articulate exactly what happened.

There's a critical difference between painting an ambitious future and lying about the present.

Elon Musk continues to promise full self-driving "next year". But then… it doesn’t happen. Yet Tesla maintains customer loyalty because Musk clearly frames these as future goals, not current capabilities.

Buyers know exactly what they're getting today versus what's promised tomorrow.

Contrast that with Theranos… Elizabeth Holmes claimed her technology could run 200 tests from a finger prick. The technology never worked, but she pitched it as ready to go. And that’s what you call fraud.

The difference is transparency about the current state. Buyers forgive missed timelines on future visions, but they don’t forgive lies about what exists today.

The path forward requires discipline.

Acknowledge limitations proactively. "Here's what we do exceptionally well, and here's where we have gaps" builds far more trust than pretending you're perfect.

Use precise language. Replace "coming soon" with "targeted for Q3 release, though timelines can shift." Replace "we're working on it" with "it's on our roadmap for next year, but not committed yet."

Under-promise and over-deliver. If you can get the proposal done by Wednesday, promise Friday. The relief of early delivery beats the frustration of missed commitments every time.

The reps who dominate their markets long-term are the ones buyers trust completely. That trust becomes the competitive advantage because once you have it, nobody can compete on equal footing.

Happy selling, my friends.